Program Review
All academic degree programs must undergo thorough review every five years according to the State University of New York. The Undergraduate Committee of the SUNY Faculty Senate in cooperation with representatives of the Faculty Council of Community Colleges developed the Guide for the Evaluation of Undergraduate Academic Programs to encourage improvement through a self-study process of planning, implementing, and evaluating. Although program review is on a five year cycle, institutions should collect, analyze, and use data continuously. The mission, goals, and objectives of the program and the institution provide the necessary framework for evaluation. All activities derive their relevance from this framework. Consequently, assessment of the program evaluates the collective effectiveness of the activities in achieving the mission, goals and objectives.
Similarly, mission, goals, and objectives determine the appropriate criteria, standards, and measures for a program review. Quality is difficult to define; consequently, faculty, students, and administrators should all engage in the dialogue to clarify its meaning in the program being reviewed. Using multiple measures to collect comprehensive sets of data results in more valid assessments of quality and success. Open sharing and interpretation of data encourage the use of evidence to support conclusions. Primary responsibility for assessment rests with the faculty, administrators and staff directly involved in the program.
Documents necessary for Program Review at SUNY Cobleskill:
- SUNY Guide for the Evaluation of Undergraduate Academic Programs, January 2012 (PDF, 0.3Mb, link updated 1/22/19)
- SUNY Cobleskill Academic Program Review Suggested Timeline and Process, 2026-2031 (updated 4/15/26)
- SUNY Cobleskill Schedule of Program Review, 2024-2030 (PDF, 0.5 Mb, Updated 9/25/25)
- Program Review Self Study Templates
- Associate Program Self-Study Template
- Bachelor Program Self-Study Template
- Final Presentation Template
This is the template that programs will utilize at the conclusion of the self-study process to present their findings to Academic Council.
- SUNY Cobleskill Guide for External Review Process:
- External Reviewers Worksheet (Word document, 0.04Mb)
- Outline for External Review Report (Word document, 0.03Mb, Updated 2/11/19)
- External Reviewers Honorarium form (Form Fillable PDF, 0.04Mb, updated 2/26/20)